Here is the final set of sim results. These add late surrender indices. All of the listed systems were re-run with late surrender. There are no results for the HiLo+AA78mTc variants because late surrender was never requested for those variants. I will not be running late surrender for those variants. These will be the final sim results.
Say what you will about the complexity of bjanalyst's systems (and I agree that they are complex), these final results show more than a trivial improvement in all of the tested scenarios over HiOpt II + ASC when late surrender is added. As pointed out in another thread, one can continue to add side counts to just about any system in order to achieve the goal of outperforming another given system. The issue will always end up being one of whether the additions to the system are practical and worth the extra effort.
Finally, I will repeat this: None of this is an endorsement from me of these or any other systems.
Code:
Scenario System Source SCORE Delta
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Play-All 1-8
HiLo Full Indices Gronbog 40.09
HiOpt II + ASC Gronbog 52.47 30.88%
KO+5m7c+AA89mTc+b sim 9 Gronbog 54.51 3.89%
Play-All 1-10
HiLo Full Indices Gronbog 46.70
HiOpt II + ASC Gronbog 59.63 27.69%
KO+5m7c+AA89mTc+b sim 9 Gronbog 62.31 4.49%
Play-All 1-12
HiLo Full Indices Gronbog 51.64
HiOpt II + ASC Gronbog 64.94 25.76%
KO+5m7c+AA89mTc+b sim 9 Gronbog 68.19 5.00%
Back-Count 1-1
HiLo Full Indices Gronbog 65.56
HiOpt II + ASC Gronbog 75.42 15.04%
KO+5m7c+AA89mTc+b sim 9 Gronbog 81.17 7.62%
Back-Count 1-2
HiLo Full Indices Gronbog 78.24
HiOpt II + ASC Gronbog 90.82 16.08%
KO+5m7c+AA89mTc+b sim 9 Gronbog 97.00 6.80%
Back-Count 1-4
HiLo Full Indices Gronbog 86.06
HiOpt II + ASC Gronbog 98.80 14.80%
KO+5m7c+AA89mTc+b sim 9 Gronbog 106.16 7.45%
Back-Count 1-8
HiLo Full Indices Gronbog 88.18
HiOpt II + ASC Gronbog 102.08 15.76%
KO+5m7c+AA89mTc+b sim 9 Gronbog 109.45 7.22%
Back-Count 1-12
HiLo Full Indices Gronbog 89.40
HiOpt II + ASC Gronbog 102.94 15.15%
KO+5m7c+AA89mTc+b sim 9 Gronbog 110.83 7.66%
Unrestricted
HiLo Full Indices Gronbog 90.01
HiOpt II + ASC Gronbog 103.25 14.71%
KO+5m7c+AA89mTc+b sim 9 Gronbog 111.38 7.87%
Bookmarks