H17 Soft 19 vs 6

**Gramazeka** · 09-18-2022, 08:49 AM

Originally Posted by Tarzan

I have it at +1 for both S17 and H17 also.

This is contrary to mathematics.

**Tarzan** · 09-22-2022, 06:17 PM

Originally Posted by Gramazeka

This is contrary to mathematics.

If I put the composition dependent indices for A,8vs6 S17 and H17 side by side, the differences are slight enough that if you made a Venn diagram of it, you'd have a 96% overlap. The differences are slight enough to be negligible. Any accurate means of index generation will show the same result. Please explain what you are referring to.

**Gramazeka** · 09-24-2022, 08:34 AM

Originally Posted by Tarzan

If I put the composition dependent indices for A,8vs6 S17 and H17 side by side, the differences are slight enough that if you made a Venn diagram of it, you'd have a 96% overlap. The differences are slight enough to be negligible. Any accurate means of index generation will show the same result. Please explain what you are referring to.

I have a difference of 1.3 TC between these indexes, as you can see from my image. It's too much for them to be the same.